I've been trying to figure out why so many of today's comics don't interest me. The obvious answer is that they aren't written or drawn with me in mind – but I still like the old stuff and I don't think that's just because of a nostalgic glow. Not that I would discount nostalgic glow entirely.
There are plenty of exceptions but speaking for the rank and file of today's comics as I've watched them over the years, they seem adult without being particularly grown-up. The characters seem very worldly but I have a hard time recognizing them as people that actually exist in the world. I understand exaggeration – we are talking about a super-powered set – but for all the naiveté ascribed to the old-timey comics for kids, there seemed a good deal more emotional sophistication.
Taking the wildest example, the Mort Weisinger Superman line – it may have indulged in childlike story constructs but that silliness was balanced somewhat by a real sense of life in the characters. Superman was good-hearted, actually strong and brave beneath his super-powers but he could be prankish, smug, and derisive, sometimes unlikable, with a fascination for all things big, big, big.
But he also had a deep sadness in him and it wasn't because the comic actually billboarded this emotion on to him with pyrotechnic angst. To follow the comics the reader would become aware of how much guilt Superman carried with him – and his palpable sense of loneliness. The whole Superman family had a not very heroic, in fact sadistic, side to them and it was these character flaws, their stories often using Superman as a kind of chorus-conscious, that made them interesting.
Lois was in love but she was jealous to a fault, demonstrably intelligent if crafty to the point of annoyance. Jimmy could be gullible and impulsive but he could also be genuinely clever. Moreover, he was a hyper-conceited self-styled ladies man stuck on a trophy-wife fantasy of a woman who clearly believed he was beneath her.
Today's Superman family features a somewhat shallow hick from the sticks made big-time – a Kansas-fed boy scout except when he is trying to be Batman. Lois is a tough talking sophisticate torn from some television or movie version of some celebrity personality ripped from today's headlines. Jimmy is just a geek. For all the adultish trappings of strong language, slit skirts and grunge hairstyles the characters in many ways have been dumbed down from their salad days counterparts.
The dark soup of today's writing is reflected in the art as well. As the old pros of the Silver Age were retiring and the new blood of the Bronze Age brought a craft both retro and modern to the times, after those fans-turned-pros dropped out, the quality of art in comics practically cratered. Simple things like shoulders and elbows became great mysteries to the new breed. That time has thankfully passed and the art in comics today is generally pretty slick. So slick, it too seems removed from any authentic emotional valance. The expressive use of anatomy and expression seems more guided by photo references – and the most archly posed of photographs at that -- than through a personality felt somehow to be pushing the pencils and pens.
When some idiosyncrasy is injected in the art it self-consciously derives its cues from the styles of artists it might imitate (or transliterate if art were a language) but can't really begin to match in spontaneity – put to the service of delineating, if not exactly breathing life, into characters too thin to treat as anything but as the latest, the newest and the nowest – because those slogans more than not define the virtues and vices of our super enclaves today.
Don't get me wrong. The old comics – across the board -- are riddled with mediocrity. But the creators aimed for fun and I think they captured a warm pulse, for all their inanity.
Today's comics leave me cold. I think it's because they are cold. Maybe the world has become cold too and that's how comics have to be to remain commercial (beyond of course their potentiality as toy designs and movie springboards).
Recollection of warmer times, as a kind of suspended innocence, is of course the basis of nostalgia. But I have noticed as time goes on and buyers of comics a decade or so (or more) grow older they seem less nostalgic about the four-color fantasies of their youth but perfectly content to bring those comics right up to date with them – like maybe there is something worth slabbing in all this junk.
And I can't say I blame them.
Sunday, October 16, 2011
Are Today's Comics Cold?
One of these days I'll get back to the Green Lantern history I started posting in June. I've rewritten Part 3 twice, but I'm not satisfied yet. Meanwhile, here's a letter that was recently posted on the Yahoo Silver Age/Golden Age group (SAGA) by "John D." It reflects so many of my own feelings about modern comic books that I asked John for permission to copy it here. Take it away, John:
Saturday, July 2, 2011
Bunny Bash 2011
Earlier this week, my wife Patty and I attended the 30th annual Bunny Bash. It was the fifth one for me. The weather was perfect, and we had a great time. (As usual, you can click on any of the following pictures to enlarge.)

The Bunny in question is our hostess, Bunny Hoest. In 1982, she and her husband Bill, creator of The Lockhorns, threw a party for fellow cartoonists and their family and friends in their beautiful home in Lloyd Neck, NY.
A tradition began, and cartoonists from near and far have gathered on her huge patio every June since then. Though I'm not a professional cartoonist myself, the Now and Then column that I write for Hogan's Alley Magazine has earned me the invitation to rub elbows with the rich and/or famous.
The even larger back yard boasts a magnificent view of Long Island Sound.
Though Bill passed on over twenty years ago, Bunny continues to write The Lockhorns, and John Reiner illustrates it in Bill's classic style.
This week, Bunny's son and his family were visiting from out of state, and brought along Oz, their Bernese Mountain Dog puppy. I was told that, despite a strong resemblance, Oz is not related to Howard Huge.
Two first-time visitors to the Bunny Bash were Greg Walker (Beetle Bailey) and Jeff Keane (The Family Circus)

They very kindly contributed a couple of drawings to my autograph/sketchbook, which I began in 1994. (It's volume two. Volume one was from 1971 to 1994.)
Above, Emilio Squeglio (Captain Marvel) shows Tony Tallarico a cover design he's working on for a future issue of Alter Ego magazine. Tony was also kind enough to give me a sketch of the title character from his Find Freddie books.
Gahan Wilson, another first-timer, added the fourth new sketch to my book. Above, he's doing another drawing for cartoonist and right-fielder Ken Krimstein.
Adrian Sinnott, president of the Berndt Toast Gang, is chatting with Greg Walker.
The crowd gathered when Adrian offered a toast to the memory of the late Lee Ames, who passed away last month. In the center of this picture,wearing sunglasses, is Dan Danglo (Felix the Cat), who will be the subject of my next Hogan's Alley column, later this year.
Stan Goldberg added a personal drawing to a hardcover collection of his Archie comic book work for fan Jerry Jurman.
A wonderful time was had by all. Thanks very much, Bunny. It was hard to say goodbye to you and all our cartoon friends.
'Til next year!
.
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Green Lantern: the 1950s
(Part 3 in a series -- click here for Part 1.)
The comic book superheroes that were so popular in the 1940s didn’t fare as well in the fifties. By 1951, most of DC’s superheroes had been cancelled. The only ones that hung on were Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and a few minor characters that appeared as back-up features in their magazines. Captain Marvel, published by Fawcett Comics, held out till 1954, and Plastic Man, a Quality character, made it to 1956, but most of the heroes of the Golden Age vanished from the stands and faded from most people’s minds.
Other genres filled the comic book racks: Westerns, war, romance, comedy, horror, detective stories, animal stories, and so on. Since it was expensive and time-consuming to file the paperwork required by the US Postal Service to launch a new magazine, DC created a title called Showcase, in which they could test out new ideas before giving them their own series. In 1956, editor Julius Schwartz decided that enough time had passed to give superheroes another try. Schwartz thought the current crop of comic book readers were too young to remember the heroes of ten years ago. He chose to bring back the Flash, a favorite of his and a strong seller in the forties. But instead of a mere revival, he and his staff created a new Flash, with the same name and powers (super-speed) but a new, modernized costume, origin story, and secret identity.
“SOS Green Lantern” in Showcase #22 (October 1959) told the story of Abin Sur, an alien patrolman in a vast intergalactic peacekeeping organization, whose spacecraft had been damaged in a radiation storm, forcing him to crash-land on Earth. Dying, it was his final responsibility to choose a replacement from the local population. He chose Hal Jordan, a test pilot, for his fearlessness, honesty, and strong will. He gave Hal his uniform and Power Ring, and a Power Battery which must be used to recharge the ring once every 24 hours. Abin explained that the ring’s green beam had nearly unlimited power; but due to an odd impurity in the metal that formed the Battery, it had no effect on anything colored yellow. Hal accepted the responsibility as Abin Sur breathed his last. Hal donned the uniform and, using the ring, concealed Abin’s body and spaceship underneath a mountain. Wanting to keep his identity a secret from the public, Hal added a mask and called himself Green Lantern, after the lantern-like Power Battery.
Some science fiction fans have noticed parallels between Green Lantern and the Lensmen series of novels by Edward Elmer “Doc” Smith, first serialized in Amazing Stories in 1934. The Lensmen of the Galactic Patrol were a corps of humans selected by aliens from the planet Arisia to defend the galaxy against the tyrannical Eddorians. They were each equipped with a Lens, a crystal that bonded itself to the arm of the owner and provided him with telepathic abilities. Julie Schwartz was a noted longtime science fiction fan, so the inspiration seems obvious; but Schwartz and Broome insisted that they were not familiar with Lensmen when they created the new Green Lantern.
In the other two stories in that Showcase issue, “Secret of the Flaming Spear” and “Menace of the Runaway Missile,” Hal thwarted saboteurs’ attacks on Ferris Aircraft, the manufacturer for which he tested jets. We met his girlfriend, Carol Ferris, the boss’s daughter. But when Carl Ferris announced that he was taking a two-year around-the-world vacation and leaving Carol in charge of the company, her relationship with Hal became strictly business – at least, until Carol met and fell for the mysterious, masked Green Lantern.
The comic book superheroes that were so popular in the 1940s didn’t fare as well in the fifties. By 1951, most of DC’s superheroes had been cancelled. The only ones that hung on were Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and a few minor characters that appeared as back-up features in their magazines. Captain Marvel, published by Fawcett Comics, held out till 1954, and Plastic Man, a Quality character, made it to 1956, but most of the heroes of the Golden Age vanished from the stands and faded from most people’s minds.

It took a while, but after four Showcase tryouts over two years, the new Flash proved to be a hit, and got his own comic book in 1959. A few months later, Julie Schwartz tried to do the same thing again, this time with Green Lantern.
But the fifties was a decade of science and technological wonders: atomic energy, television, space rockets, computers, and automatic home appliances. Magic lamps wouldn’t cut it with the new generation. Instead of bringing back the old Green Lantern, he and writer John Broome created a new version to appeal to science fiction fans.


The seemingly arbitrary weakness to yellow actually had a bit of reasoning behind it. First of all, in those early days, the writers of superhero stories wanted super-powered characters to be fairly uncommon, so super-villains were not yet in vogue. Most adversaries were common criminals, gangsters, and spies with no special powers. So, to keep the stories interesting, powerful heroes had to be given some sort of Achilles’ heel to give their opponents a fighting chance. The more powerful the hero, the more mundane the weakness had to be. Second, the choice of a color as opposed to a substance (like Alan Scott’s wood limitation, or Superman’s kryptonite) was more visual, so the reader could instantly identify what objects posed a threat to GL. Third, it made a certain awkward kind of sense from a scientific standpoint, since GL’s power was light-based, and color, to a physicist, is the property of reflecting specific wavelengths of light. And fourth, it was symbolic, as Hal was chosen for his bravery, and yellow, in American culture, is traditionally associated with cowardice.
One element retained from the forties Green Lantern was the oath. The new Green Lantern spoke the same words as the earlier version when recharging his ring with the lantern:
Schwartz insisted that each Green Lantern story include the oath. Since comics are a silent medium, Schwartz believed that the charging of the ring and the speaking of the oath served the same purpose as a musical crescendo in a movie. It let the audience know that something significant was about to happen.
One element retained from the forties Green Lantern was the oath. The new Green Lantern spoke the same words as the earlier version when recharging his ring with the lantern:
"In brightest day, in blackest night,
No evil shall escape my sight.
Let those who worship evil's might
Beware my power.
Green Lantern's light!"
Schwartz insisted that each Green Lantern story include the oath. Since comics are a silent medium, Schwartz believed that the charging of the ring and the speaking of the oath served the same purpose as a musical crescendo in a movie. It let the audience know that something significant was about to happen.

Artist Gil Kane designed a uniform for Hal that was sleeker and far less garish than the outfit worn by Alan Scott. The new design was a simple green and black suit with lines that followed the musculature of the body, and no belt or cape to break the flow. White gloves were a peculiar addition, but somehow they worked. Penciled by Kane and inked by Joe Giella, the figure of Green Lantern seemed to glide gracefully through the air more skillfully than Superman.

![]() |
In Showcase #23, the science fiction element was more pronounced, as Green Lantern had his first offworld adventure. A mysterious telepathic voice from the Power Battery ordered him to the planet Venus, where he rescued a primitive tribe of humanoids threatened by pterodactyl-like creatures. Here Hal learned of another of his ring’s functions: the ability to translate languages. In the second story, Green Lantern was challenged by the Invisible Destroyer, an evil being of pure energy that sprang from the subconscious imagination of a famous atomic scientist.
![]() |
The third and last Green Lantern Showcase issue contained “The Secret of the Black Museum,” another tale of spies and espionage, and “The Creature That Couldn’t Die,” a typical 1950s SF movie plot about a giant monster on a rampage, but with a twist ending.
At the end of that story, a note from the editor asked the readers to write in and tell him if they wanted to see more of Green Lantern. But while Julie waited for the reader responses to come in, he didn’t take the chance that GL would fade from their memories. Two months after Showcase #24 came out, its companion magazine, The Brave and the Bold, followed up with a three-issue tryout for the Justice League of America, a team consisting of all of DC’s superhero characters. Green Lantern joined forces with Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, the Flash, Aquaman, and the Martian Manhunter in B&B #28–30, to combat Starro the Conqueror (a giant starfish from space, inspired by a pulp science fiction story entitled Tyranno the Conqueror), Xotar the Weapons Master, and Amazo, an android with the combined powers of all the Justice Leaguers. Sales on all the tryouts must have been good, because in the summer of 1960, both Green Lantern and the Justice League of America were starring in their own magazines.
(Click here for the next chapter.)
(Click here for the next chapter.)
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Green Lantern: the 1940s
(Part 2 in a series -- click here for Part 1.)

In 1939, after doing a few humor-strip assignments for All-American (later DC) Comics, he asked editor Sheldon Mayer if he could get more steady work. Superman had debuted a year earlier in Action Comics, and had been a surprise hit. Mayer told Nodell that if he could come up with an original superhero character to rival Superman, then he could have a regular job drawing it.

The green lantern -- a sign that all is safe. The green lantern. Nodell liked the sound of those words. It brought to mind the story of Aladdin from 1,001 Arabian Nights -- the boy who had a magic lamp and a magic ring which put powerful genies at his command. The more he thought about it, the more he liked it.
Nodell wrote an origin story for his new character, and drew up some sample pages that he brought to Mayer. Mayer found the artwork a little rough, but thought the concept was a powerful one. He partnered Nodell with Batman writer Bill Finger, and together they reworked the story. Nodell, inspired by Aladdin, had named his hero "Alan Ladd." Finger thought this sounded too contrived, and changed the last name to "Scott." Neither of them realized at the time that there was a character actor named Alan Ladd who would become a big name in Hollywood in a couple of years.
The story told of Alan Scott, a young engineer who was the only survivor of a train crash when a bridge built by Alan's construction company collapsed. Alan was certain that the accident was an act of sabotage by a rival company, but had no proof. Absent-mindedly clutching a green train lantern, Alan felt faint and passed out, as the lantern began to glow brightly.
Alan then had a dream of a meteorite that crashed in ancient China and burned with a green flame, and a voice that spoke a prophecy of bringing death, life, and power. When the meteorite cooled, an old lamp maker forged an oil lamp from its metal. An angry mob, frightened that the lamp contained an evil power, killed the lamp maker and wrecked his shop. But the lamp glowed with a bright green flame, killing the mob and enacting first part of the prophecy.
Now, a voice from the lantern told Alan, it was time for the third and final part of the prophecy to be realized. The lantern told Alan to make a ring from part of its metal. By touching the ring to the lantern once every 24 hours, he would have the power that was promised centuries ago. Alan did as he was told. With his newfound power ring, he forced a confession from the saboteurs, who thought him to be a ghost.
Realizing that he could do much good, he made himself a costume "so bizarre that once I am seen I will never be forgotten" and spoke a solemn vow: “And I shall shed my light over dark evil, for the dark things cannot stand the light… the light of the Green Lantern!”
Bizarre certainly was the word for Alan’s costume: a red puffy-sleeved shirt with a green-and-yellow lantern insignia on the chest, green tights, red boots, a wide brown leather belt, purple mask, and a high-collared purple cape with a light green lining. Clearly, fashion sense was not one of his powers.
The first Green Lantern story appeared in All-American Comics #16, with the date of July 1940 on the cover. He appeared every month in All-American Comics, and proved popular enough to become a regular feature in Comics Cavalcade and as a member of the Justice Society of America in All-Star Comics. He soon earned his own magazine, Green Lantern Quarterly, the fourth of only five DC superheroes in the 1940s to have a self-titled comic book. With issue #19 in 1946, the Green Lantern magazine changed from quarterly to bimonthly.

Originally, Alan recharged his ring either silently or while reciting the oath mentioned above. In 1942, there must have been a communication breakdown among the writers, because during that year Alan spoke no fewer than six different oaths in various stories:
"Let the light of the lantern penetrate the dark places of ignorance and wrong,
setting all minds right and overthrowing all servants of evil!"
"I shed my light upon the darkness!
Evil has no place to hide itself!
Green Lantern goes forth to conquer!"
"My rays strike the darkest corner,
Banishing all wickedness!"
"Let all power and triumph be mine in whatever right I do!"
"The light of the Green Lantern pierces darkness and mystery,
And its radiance will strike at the heart of evil!"
"As the green rays strike forth into darkness,
So may all black evil be exposed and driven away!"
In the fall of 1943, when noted science fiction author Alfred Bester became the regular writer of the Green Lantern series, the oath took the form that has lasted practically unchanged to the present day:
"In brightest day, in darkest night,
No evil shall escape my sight.
Let those who worship evil's might
Beware my power,
Green Lantern's light!"
This oath first appeared in Comic Cavalcade #4, All-American #53, and Green Lantern #9, all of which came out about the same month, making it hard to determine which was first. A few months later, the word “darkest” was changed to “blackest.” Though Bester is usually credited with creating this oath, he stated in an interview at the 1979 World Science Fiction Convention that it was already being used before he began writing Green Lantern.


(Click here for the next chapter.)
Saturday, May 21, 2011
Green Lantern and Me
(Part 1 in a series)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) and I both arrived into the world in the same month back in 1959. Almost since I could read, he's been my favorite superhero. When I was a little kid, fascinated by the all the colorful costumes and exciting super-powers, GL was unique. In a sea of bright red, blue, and yellow capes and masks, his simple, sleek green-and-black uniform made him stand out visually. And in a crowd of muscle men, rubber men, fish-men, bird-men, acrobats, gadgeteers, speedsters, archers, shapeshifters, and size-changers, his power to solidify light into any object he could imagine was different from anything else out there.
That power was a big reason that the Green Lantern concept appealed to me. I was a quiet kid. I never got into any physical fights. My fantasies never involved smashing things, or beating people up. Green Lantern's power was such that he never had to beat anyone up. He could simply restrain his opponents by imagining a big green birdcage or a puddle of green glue. His was a power that was creative and imaginative, not destructive.

I preferred seeing Green Lantern in the Justice League of America comic book. There, among mega-powered heroes like Superman, the Flash, and Wonder Woman, he exercised his imagination to the utmost. More often than not, GL was the hero who would save the day by the story's end. That's another reason he appealed to me. While all superheroes rescue ordinary people, GL was the one who rescued other superheroes.
I've always been something of a science and science fiction geek as well as a comics fan, and Green Lantern was one of the most science-fiction oriented superhero comics of the '60s. That isn't surprising, because editor Julius Schwartz and writers John Broome and Gardner Fox all came to comics from a background in science fiction publishing. Green Lantern wasn't an independent agent like most superheroes. he was a member of a vast intergalactic police force, all armed with identical power rings. His adventures routinely took him to far-off planets and other time periods. He often teamed up with other Green Lanterns from alien races, many of which weren't even remotely humanoid. They all reported to the Guardians of the Universe, a council of benevolent, immortal, blue-skinned beings who all looked identical. (Kane, who loved to include caricatures in his work, based their features on Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion. For the record, Kane based Hal Jordan's face on actor Paul Newman, and girlfriend Carol Ferris on Elizabeth Taylor.) Schwartz, recognizing that the typical Green Lantern reader was a bit more scholarly that the average comic book reader, liked to include scientific facts and trivia in the magazine, both within the stories and in separate fun-facts pages.
![]() |
My first Green Lantern issue: #45 (June, 1966) |
Best of all, reporter Lois Lane believed that Clark Kent was really Superman, but all her attempts to prove it backfired on her; while reporter Sue Williams believed that Jim Jordan, Hal's younger brother, was really Green Lantern, but all his attempts to disprove it backfired on him. There were only a few Jordan Brothers stories, but they were a lot of fun. Jim and Sue eventually got married and had children, but nothing would shake Sue's conviction that she was secretly married to Green Lantern.
Many writers and artists have put their mark on Green Lantern in the past fifty years. Many of them have tried to reinvent the character to fit their own distinct ideas about what he should be. Along with the standard hero-versus-villain fights, Green Lantern has been used to tell stories of grand space adventure, Cold War-era espionage, social commentary, soap opera, religious allegory, and satire. Hal Jordan has had about a half dozen changes of career, and about a dozen different girlfriends. He's been exiled from Earth, come back, quit the Green Lantern Corps, rejoined, destroyed the Corps (twice), turned super-villain, redeemed himself, died, and come back to life. Through it all, Green Lantern (in one form or another) has survived.
Over the next few weeks, I plan to write a series of posts on the history of Green Lantern. If you're going to see the movie but aren't too familiar with the character, you may want to drop by for a crash course. Even if you're a longtime GL fan, you may learn a fact or two that you didn't know. Stay tuned.
(Click here for the next chapter.)
Thursday, February 3, 2011
The Cold Hard Truth
A number of people have mailed me a link to this look back at Calvin's snow sculptures. They're terrific, but let's not ignore the fact that Linus beat him to it by about 30 years:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)